1. Fur & Loathing ("Big Cat" Scott Henson & Kaden Talbain)
(9/2/12, aired 10/15/12) Scott Henson & Yakuza J [O] beat Dangerous Dave Devereaux & Jonathan Hitler [X] via Northern Lights Bomb in tournament final* (13:29)
*Scott Henson & Kaden Talbain were original entries for their team in tournament, so they win the titles despite Yakuza replacing Talbain in the finals
- V1: (6/14/13, aired 8/15/13) Fur & Loathing {Scott Henson [O] & Kaden Talbain} beat Feeling 22 {Zayne & Brad Rush [X]} via CRITICAL! Championship Edition (17:03)
- V2: (7/12/13, aired 9/17/13) Fur & Loathing {Scott Henson [O] & Kaden Talbain} beat Drew Sarian & Domi [X] via CRITICAL! Championship Edition (7:16)
- V3: (2/1/14, aired 7/31/14) Fur & Loathing {"Big Cat" Scott Henson [O] & Kaden Talbain} beat Rain City Coalition {Daniel Makabe [X] & Drew Sarian} via Burning Bright (21:21)
- V4: (6/14/14, aired 8/25/14) Fur & Loathing {"Big Cat" Scott Henson [O] & Kaden Talbain} beat Joey Tornado [X] & Jack Diesel via CRITICAL! Championship Edition (3:17)
- V5: (2/11/15) Fur & Loathing {"Big Cat" Scott Henson & Kaden Talbain [O]} beat Rain City Coalition {Daniel Makabe [X] & Drew Sarian} via Deadlift Brainbuster (24:25)

2. Rain City Coalition (Daniel Makabe & Drew Sarian)
(4/18/15) Rain City Coalition {Daniel Makabe [O] & Drew Sarian [O]} beat Fur & Loathing {"Big Cat" Scott Henson [X] & Kaden Talbain [X]} via Jim Breaks Armbar & Tiger Tamer (14:22)

3. retired
(3/11/16) title retired due to breakup of team